Humphrey's first Brownlow votes came on Anzac weekend of 2025, when he had 18 disposals and four majors against Sydney. He backed it up with 20 and 24 touches over the next fortnight, added three-goal hauls against Brisbane, Richmond and Fremantle, and finished the year with the Gold Coast Suns' Emerging Player award and a top-four place in the club champion count. He has played 83 AFL games and kicked 72 goals.