Crisp broke the V/AFL record for consecutive games in 2025, passing the mark previously held by Jim Stynes. The left-footer has won two Copeland Trophies, in 2021 and 2022, took the Bob Rose Award as Collingwood's best player in the 2023 finals and the Neale Daniher Trophy in 2024, and was part of the Magpies' 2023 premiership team. He has played 298 AFL games and kicked 102 goals.