Taken with pick 19 in the 2025 national draft from the Geelong Falcons, Lindsay arrived rated among the most composed left-footers of his class after under-18 All-Australian selection and a Coates Talent League Team of the Year berth. The 183cm defender kicked his first goal in a Western Derby and earned a round 10 Rising Star nomination as a debutant. He has played 15 AFL games and kicked 1 goal.